BLOG

Selling on Shopify, Amazon and TikTok Shop? How to Decide Where Your Budget Goes

Written by Sarah Carusona

Where should your budget go? Shopify, Amazon and TikTok Shop

If you’re running a business across Shopify, Amazon and TikTok Shop, are you ever confused about where to put your budget?

Amazon looks like your most profitable channel. Shopify ROAS seems to get worse every month. And TikTok Shop? On paper, you’re losing money on every order.

So you do the responsible thing. You move budget to where you see a profit.

And somehow, sales don’t go up.

I’ve run 7, 8 and 9-figure P&Ls, and at BA Commerce we work with $5-50M DTC brands. I’ve seen a lot of multichannel businesses, and the same mistake shows up over and over: judging each channel on its own. Here’s how to do it instead. Know your CM1 and CM2 for each channel, set one CM2 target for the whole business, then give each channel a target that fits its job. In the $10M example below, that’s Amazon at 35%, Shopify at 25% and TikTok Shop at a planned -15%, which still lands around 25% overall.

Step 1: What’s your margin by channel?

Not blended. Each channel on its own.

You need two numbers. CM1 is what you keep after making and delivering the product. CM2 is what you keep after advertising.

Let’s use Harvey Chow, the fictional dog brand from the P&L article. Dog food, supplements and gadgets, about $10M a year. 62% of revenue comes from Shopify, 30% from Amazon and 8% from TikTok Shop.

Example brand Harvey Chow split by channel: Shopify 62% of revenue, Amazon 30%, TikTok Shop 8%. CM1 of 50%, 44% and 44%; CM2 of 21%, 33% and -20%

CM1 by channel

Shopify keeps about 50%. Amazon and TikTok Shop both keep about 44%.

Why lower? Both platforms take a cut of every order. On Amazon, the referral fee is 15% of the sale in most categories, and FBA and storage fees come on top. On TikTok Shop you pay a commission on every sale, and you’re usually still shipping it yourself.

To be fair, FBA replaces the shipping and fulfillment you’d pay for anyway on Shopify. But after fees, both marketplaces keep less than your own site.

So far Shopify looks like the best channel. Hold that thought.

CM2 by channel

Now take out the ad spend for each channel.

Amazon: about 33%. The best of the three.

Shopify: about 21%.

TikTok Shop: negative 20%. For every dollar Harvey Chow sells on TikTok Shop, they lose 20 cents after ads and affiliate commissions.

After ads, Amazon keeps 33%, Shopify 21% and TikTok Shop -20%. Check what TikTok Shop does for the other channels before you cut it

So the answer’s obvious, right? Move budget to Amazon and shut off TikTok Shop.

No.

Step 2: How do Amazon, Shopify and TikTok Shop work together?

You have to hold two things in your head at once.

  1. Customer behavior is messy. People see your ad on Instagram, watch a creator on TikTok, then buy on Amazon a week later. Unless you’re $50M or more, stop trying to attribute every sale perfectly. You won’t.

  2. Your budget still needs a reason. Put it where you have data to back it up.

Amazon is mostly demand capture. When someone goes to Amazon, they already have a product or a problem in mind. They’re at the bottom of the funnel, so they’re cheaper to convert.

It’s like Google versus Meta. You’d never judge your Google ROAS the same way you judge Meta. Someone searching “grain-free dog food” is way closer to buying than someone scrolling Instagram.

So yes, Amazon looks the most profitable. But Amazon can only grow because other channels create the demand. Mostly Meta, which sends people to your Shopify store, and TikTok. That’s where people first see you.

Meta, TikTok and creators create demand; Amazon and Google capture it. Cut the top and Amazon has less demand to capture

Why can TikTok Shop run at a loss?

On its own, that -20% looks bad. But look at what you get for it: affiliates making videos about your product, and a lot more people seeing it.

Then you take those same videos and run them as ads on Meta. Content you’d otherwise pay a lot to make.

TikTok Shop isn’t just a sales channel. It’s your content engine and your awareness engine. The question isn’t “is TikTok Shop profitable?” It’s “what job is it doing, and how much am I willing to spend for it?”

Cut Meta and TikTok to fund Amazon, and a few months later there’s less demand for Amazon to capture. That’s why moving budget to the channel that looks profitable doesn’t make sales go up.

Step 3: How do you set each channel’s budget?

Start with one CM2 target for the whole DTC business. Not per channel. Total.

Harvey Chow is at about 21% CM2 today. Say the goal is 25%.

If you judged every channel on its own, you’d ask each one to hit 25%. And you’d cut TikTok Shop on day one.

Instead, work backwards from the total:

  1. Amazon captures demand, so push it: 35% CM2.

  2. TikTok Shop’s job is content and awareness, so accept a loss: -15% CM2.

  3. Shopify, where your Meta spend sends people, sits around 25%.

With the mix (62% Shopify, 30% Amazon, 8% TikTok Shop), that lands right around 25% total.

One total target: Shopify at 25% CM2, Amazon at 35%, TikTok Shop at -15%, about 25% overall

Now you know what each channel can spend on ads. Start with what it keeps after making and delivering the product (its CM1), then take away its CM2 target. What’s left is the ad budget.

For example, for every $100 in sales:

  • Shopify’s CM1 is $50. Its CM2 target is $25. So it can spend $25, or 25% of sales, on ads ($50 - $25).

  • Amazon’s CM1 is $44. Its CM2 target is $35. So it can spend $9, or 9% of sales, on ads ($44 - $35).

  • TikTok Shop’s CM1 is $44. Its CM2 target is -$15, a loss you’ve planned for. So it can spend $59, or 59% of sales, on ads and affiliates ($44 + $15). That’s a plan, not a mistake.

That’s a budget set from your margins and the job each channel does. Not from whichever channel had the best ROAS last week.

How do you judge each channel against its target?

These targets aren’t set in stone. Measure every channel against its target, but always in the context of the total.

Hitting the total, with Amazon a little below and Shopify and TikTok a little above? Great. Keep scaling.

Missing the total? That’s when you dig in. Which channel is off, why, and how do you fix it?

Example: your Amazon sales start dropping. At the same time, that product is getting fewer affiliate posts on TikTok Shop. Those two things are probably connected.

Use channel numbers to diagnose. Not to judge each channel on its own.

Someone has to own that total target. That’s the box on top in How to Structure a $10M Ecommerce Team.

Recap

  1. Know your CM1 and CM2 for every channel.

  2. The channels work together. Amazon captures the demand Meta and TikTok create.

  3. Set one total DTC target, then decide what job each channel does and what margin it can run at.

  4. Judge the channels together, not in silos.

Pull up your P&L by channel this week and paste it into Claude with the prompt below to get your CM1 and CM2 by channel. Then ask yourself which channel you’ve been judging on its own.

The prompt (paste this into Claude with your P&L):

I'm going to give you my ecommerce P&L. Split it into a contribution margin view for each sales channel (my own site, Amazon, TikTok Shop and any others). Don't change any numbers, only move and split lines.

Revenue: gross sales for each channel, plus shipping income charged to customers, minus discounts. Use each channel's revenue as 100% for that channel's percentages.

CM1 (what I keep after making and delivering the product). Subtract for each channel: COGS (product, freight-in, packaging), returns and refunds, pick and pack / 3PL, outbound shipping and postage, payment processing, and marketplace fees (Amazon referral and FBA fees, TikTok Shop commission and fulfillment fees).

CM2 (what I keep after advertising). Subtract for each channel: the ad spend that drives it (usually Meta and Google for my own site, Amazon Ads for Amazon, TikTok ads and GMV Max for TikTok Shop), plus influencer and affiliate commissions.

Then:
1. Show a table with one column per channel plus a total: revenue, % of total revenue, CM1 ($ and %) and CM2 ($ and %).
2. List every cost you split across channels and how you split it (for example, by units or by revenue), so I can check.
3. Flag any line you couldn't assign to a channel and ask me instead of guessing.
4. Confirm the channel columns add up to my total P&L.
5. Tell me which channel looks weakest on its own, and what job it might be doing for the other channels before I cut it.
I'm going to give you my ecommerce P&L. Split it into a contribution margin view for each sales channel (my own site, Amazon, TikTok Shop and any others). Don't change any numbers, only move and split lines.

Revenue: gross sales for each channel, plus shipping income charged to customers, minus discounts. Use each channel's revenue as 100% for that channel's percentages.

CM1 (what I keep after making and delivering the product). Subtract for each channel: COGS (product, freight-in, packaging), returns and refunds, pick and pack / 3PL, outbound shipping and postage, payment processing, and marketplace fees (Amazon referral and FBA fees, TikTok Shop commission and fulfillment fees).

CM2 (what I keep after advertising). Subtract for each channel: the ad spend that drives it (usually Meta and Google for my own site, Amazon Ads for Amazon, TikTok ads and GMV Max for TikTok Shop), plus influencer and affiliate commissions.

Then:
1. Show a table with one column per channel plus a total: revenue, % of total revenue, CM1 ($ and %) and CM2 ($ and %).
2. List every cost you split across channels and how you split it (for example, by units or by revenue), so I can check.
3. Flag any line you couldn't assign to a channel and ask me instead of guessing.
4. Confirm the channel columns add up to my total P&L.
5. Tell me which channel looks weakest on its own, and what job it might be doing for the other channels before I cut it.
I'm going to give you my ecommerce P&L. Split it into a contribution margin view for each sales channel (my own site, Amazon, TikTok Shop and any others). Don't change any numbers, only move and split lines.

Revenue: gross sales for each channel, plus shipping income charged to customers, minus discounts. Use each channel's revenue as 100% for that channel's percentages.

CM1 (what I keep after making and delivering the product). Subtract for each channel: COGS (product, freight-in, packaging), returns and refunds, pick and pack / 3PL, outbound shipping and postage, payment processing, and marketplace fees (Amazon referral and FBA fees, TikTok Shop commission and fulfillment fees).

CM2 (what I keep after advertising). Subtract for each channel: the ad spend that drives it (usually Meta and Google for my own site, Amazon Ads for Amazon, TikTok ads and GMV Max for TikTok Shop), plus influencer and affiliate commissions.

Then:
1. Show a table with one column per channel plus a total: revenue, % of total revenue, CM1 ($ and %) and CM2 ($ and %).
2. List every cost you split across channels and how you split it (for example, by units or by revenue), so I can check.
3. Flag any line you couldn't assign to a channel and ask me instead of guessing.
4. Confirm the channel columns add up to my total P&L.
5. Tell me which channel looks weakest on its own, and what job it might be doing for the other channels before I cut it.

Frequently asked questions

How should I split my ad budget between Shopify, Amazon and TikTok Shop?

Set one CM2 target for the whole business, then give each channel a target that fits its job. Each channel’s ad budget is its CM1 minus its CM2 target. In the example, for every $100 in sales, Shopify can spend $25 on ads, Amazon $9 and TikTok Shop $59.

Why does Amazon look like my most profitable channel?

Amazon is mostly demand capture. People arrive with a product or a problem in mind, so they’re cheaper to convert. But Amazon can only grow because Meta and TikTok create the demand. Cut those to fund Amazon, and a few months later there’s less demand for Amazon to capture.

Is it OK for TikTok Shop to lose money?

It can be, if the loss is planned. TikTok Shop brings affiliate videos and awareness, and you can run those videos as ads on Meta. In the example, TikTok Shop runs at a planned -15% CM2 and the business still lands around a 25% total CM2.

Why do Amazon and TikTok Shop keep less margin than Shopify?

Both take a cut of every order. Amazon’s referral fee is 15% of the sale in most categories, with FBA and storage fees on top. TikTok Shop charges a commission on every sale. In the example, Shopify keeps about 50% after making and delivering the product, and both marketplaces about 44%.

Sarah Carusona, DTC growth operator and founder of BA Commerce. I’ve run 7, 8 and 9-figure P&Ls and work with $5-50M DTC brands. More on YouTube, LinkedIn and X.

WORK WITH US

Let's talk.

Month-to-month. No lock-in. No BS.

Ready to scale?
Let’s build the engine.

©2026 BA Commerce. All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy

Terms Policy

WORK WITH US

Let's talk.

Month-to-month. No lock-in. No BS.

Ready to scale?
Let’s build the engine.

©2026 BA Commerce. All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy

Terms Policy

WORK WITH US

Let's talk.

Month-to-month. No lock-in. No BS.

Ready to scale?
Let’s build the engine.

©2026 BA Commerce. All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy

Terms Policy